Ich ? prob not, but what, 7 days in, no deaths, hmm

yeah

 

bump to nicewrasses ID, thx bro

 

bump

 

It might be brook. I can't tell for 100% with the pics, but anytime I've seen "gray crap" on the sides of fish, it has been a good place to start.

Hate to say it but it probably came from the gobies, if that is all that was new recently.

 

yeah, I worried that too, but, being 5 days in, no losses and the fish still eating great, I'm guessing its not brook
blue eyed kole, still looking bad, but still eating, eyes fine
YT, went form covered to clear in 2 days
black clown, looking a little rough, almost like brook, but just not quite, and eating fine
orange clown, seems fine, but he and the YT have made it through a major ich outbreak
rest of fish, no signs at all, its, weird, it doesn look like ich and brook combined, but after over a week of first signs, no dead fish or struggling fish, which kinda makes me doubt its brook.

Wrong?