All About Reef Safe Wrasses

Discussion in 'Tropical Fish' started by evolved, Sep 12, 2011.

to remove this notice and enjoy 3reef content with less ads. 3reef membership is free.

  1. evolved

    evolved Wrasse Freak

    Joined:
    Feb 26, 2010
    Messages:
    4,257
    Location:
    Phoenix, AZ
    This article has been updated here (link).

    An excerpt of the original article is below, however it is truncated as this post exceeds the maximum length limitation of this forum.

    Introduction

    So being a self-proclaimed wrasse freak, I am taking it upon myself to sum up my knowledge and experience about keeping wrasses as best as I can. I have such a love and passion for these fish, I can’t imagine keeping a reef without one or two or ten. I’m hopeful this thread will be seeing a continual evolution, and I would also like to open it up to “all things wrasse” as well as keep it flowing with advice/Q&A. For now, I wish to proceed with attempting to capture all I know about keeping these beautiful, fascinating fish, including: what is a reef safe wrasse, general requirements, feeding, the different genera which are reef safe and appropriate caveats with each, mixing various genera and different species of the same genus, and lastly listing the more popular species within each genus and some comments on each.


    What’s a Reef Safe Wrasse?
    First, let’s discuss what qualifies as a reef safe wrasse. I consider three big breaks in the entire wrasse family which are as follows: 1) Completely reef safe, 2) Mostly reef safe, and 3) Don’t even think about it. I am only going to focus on wrasses in categories 1 and 2 for a few reasons, but mainly because the entire classification of wrasses is so large, this thread could literally be my life’s work if I didn’t scope it back accordingly. It is very true there are some wrasses in the third category that some experienced reefers keep in their reef tanks, but they are well aware of what special measures are required for such to be possible.

    Wrasses in category 1 do not pose any risk to your coral or decorate/useful invertebrates. Wrasses in category 2 also do not pose any risk to your coral, but may pose some risk to certain invertebrates. However, this risk is greatly minimized if you follow the guidelines in this thread, mainly the general guidelines listed below.

    A general note about all reef-safe wrasses: they can ship poorly, and all are easily stressed, especially during system transitions. You must be vigilant when adding a wrasse to a system and when adding new arrivals. Please give a newly added wrasse time to adjust to their new system, up to a week or two. DO NOT go disturbing your tank looking for them; this will only add stress and hurt your chances of success. This especially applies to the sand burrowing genera; don’t go dig them up just to see them.


    General Requirements
    The three big requirements for keeping wrasses, which I cannot stress enough, are:

    • Must be kept with appropriate tankmates. Basically, no “aggressive” fish. You need to have a relatively peaceful tank in order for it to be suitable for reef safe wrasses.
    • They need to be feed several times per day. If the thought of supplying small amounts of food (nutrients) to your tank several times per day makes you cringe, look elsewhere. Wrasses are very active fish, and need a variety of meaty foods often in their diet to keep them healthy.
    • Must be kept IN A COVERED TANK. This is fundamentally essential. All wrasses are jumpers. They are a deep water fish and are not instinctually used to the surface being so near to them. Keep them in an uncovered tank, or one with any gaps, and it is simply a matter of time before they go carpet surfing. On that note, a 5/8” wrasse will fit though a 5/8” hole. Don’t leave any opportunities for escape. If the head fits, the fish fits!

    Lastly, these points should go without saying, but I hate for them to go without consideration. You need to check the individual requirements of each species before you determine if a specific one is good for you. They all have their own requirements. Notably, please make sure you house them in an appropriate sized tank.


    Feeding
    Wrasses should be fed small amounts of meaty foods ~3 times per day. Offer a variety of foods. Personally, I feed a frozen meaty food twice per day and pellets for another feeding each day (I even offer nori once a week; some species will show interest, others will not). Feed small amounts dispersed throughout the tank in effort to ensure each fish gets their share, while limiting the amount to prevent excessive nutrients. Rinsing some frozen foods can help a little in the latter department. A good skimmer is a must with a wrasse-dominant system.


    Genera which are “Reef Safe”
    There are eight(ish) genera of wrasses which are considered to be reef safe and are commonly available in the trade. They are: Anampses, Cirrhilabrus, Halichoeres, Labroides, Macropharyngodon, Paracheilinus, Pseudocheilinus, Wetmorella, and one offshoot of Pseudocheilinus: Pseudocheilinops (with a single species; see the species list by genus section).

    Anampses: Often referred to as “Tamarin” wrasses, species of this genus are not for the inexperienced keeper. While this genus can be hardy if healthy and established in a system, achieving such is generally not a simple task. This genus stresses very easily in transit, and often ships quite poorly. They are also prone to injury upon collection. If you find a specimen for sale of this genus and must have it, inspect the mouth/jaws carefully and insure there is no signs of injury. I would also recommend insuring the specimen is accepting prepared foods when offered. Lastly, a sandbed is a requirement for this genus, as they will bury at night or when frightened.

    Cirrhilabrus: The crown jewel genus. Beautiful, peaceful (usually), very active, and smart, these often come with a great personality as well. These are the “Fairy” wrasses. Generally hardy, but like most wrasse genera these are also prone to shipping stress. So long as they will be entering a suitable system with compatible tankmates, this isn’t much of a concern with this genus however. Cirrhilabrus wrasses take to prepared foods very easily, and are voracious eaters. If a specimen is not eating, health concerns are certainly justified. Males are much more colorful than females for any given species within this genus. Cirrhilabrus wrasses, like most genera here, are protogynous hermaphrodites, meaning females transition to male in the wild as harem conditions and space require. Females can/may transition to male in a closed system as well, which often occurs if kept in the presence of other Cirrhilabrus wrasses of a different species in the same system. Females may be kept together with a single male of one species in the same system, but there is no guarantee a female will stay female. Mated relationships between wrasses are like that of Anthias, in that sex is maintained by a dominance/submissive hierarchical order. Species in this genus do not need a sandbed, as they will sleep within the rockwork in a mucus cocoon.

    Halichoeres: A very large genus with a wide variety of species (over 75). Only a handful of particular species are commonly offered in the trade however. Most of the ones which enter the trade fall into category 2 on the “reef safe” scale. Some however, fall into category 3 as they readily consume inverts. Those in category 2 usually do not pose a significant risk to inverts if they are feed properly. I do not hesitate to keep some wrasses of this genus in my personal reef. This genus readily accepts prepared foods and will also spend most of the day searching for food amongst the rockwork and sandbed in a tank. They will often consume ‘pods and various pests. A sandbed is a requirement for this genus, as they will bury at night or when frightened.

    Labroides: I hesitate to even include this genus, as I big reservations against even buying them, let alone keeping them or recommending them for a reef tank. These are the “cleaner” wrasses, as in the wild they remove parasites and dead scales/tissue from other reef fish. My reservations against buying/keeping this genus are due to the following two reasons: they cannot be sustained long term in a closed system as a diet of prepared foods does not offer them the range of nutrition they require, and mostly the mere collection of this species impacts the overall health of a wild reef. There are a few success stories about keeping a cleaner wrasse long term, but for each success there are hundreds of failures. Please leave this fish in the ocean where it’s best suited. If the demand for sales of these species would cease, so would their wild collection.

    Macropharyngodon: The “Leopard” wrasses. A very delicate genus, they are exceptionally prone to shipping and collection stress. These are not for the inexperienced keeper. They can also be difficult to wean onto prepared foods. Specimens for purchase should be well inspected for any trauma and ensure they are accepting prepared foods. Make sure they are actually swallowing prepared foods, as often they will spit them back out before this change in diet has been accepted. Even if a specimen is healthy and eating well, the species in this genus easily stress upon any move from one system to another. They are also quite prone to flukes and treatment with Prazi upon purchase is recommended. Once added to a new system, it is not uncommon from them to disappear in the sandbed for a week (or even up to two). Let them be. You will see them again in a few days if all goes well. Do not go dig them up. A sandbed is a requirement for this genus, as they will bury at night or when frightened.

    Paracheilinus: The “Flasher” wrasses. A very active genus with several colorful species, in many ways these are quite similar to the Cirrhilabrus genus except they remain much smaller. The common name arises naturally from the male’s behavior of “flashing”, either for territorial display or courting, where the dorsal and anal fins are erected and blood rushes to the scales, resulting in quite the display of color and posture. This is a generally hardy genus, but like the others is prone to shipping stress. However, like the Cirrhilabrus genus, this is not much concern if they are bound for an appropriate system. They are voracious eaters and take to prepared foods easily. There is also quite the discernable difference between male and females of the same species. Females are not nearly as common in the trade as divers do not often collect them due to their dull coloration in contrast to the males. Species in this genus do not need a sandbed, as they will sleep within the rockwork in a mucus cocoon.

    Pseudocheilinus: The “Lined” wrasses, such as the Sixline, Fourline, etc, but also include such species as the Mystery Wrasse. Once established in a system, they often become quite pugnacious towards new additions and are outright incompatible with other wrasses. For this reason, I prefer to avoid this genus and find myself to be not very fond of them; however they do hold some merit in the hobby as they can be a great addition in the appropriate setting. This is a very hardy genus and will readily hunt for ‘pods and pests throughout the system. Therefore, they are a great addition to frag tanks or other small systems which are not suited for the larger genera. As much of a bully as they generally are, they are also notorious for being shy when observers are around. Species in this genus do not need a sandbed, as they will sleep within the rockwork in a mucus cocoon.

    Wetmorella: The “Possum” wrasses. A very shy and docile genus, they can be a bit cryptic at times in a system. They do not often exceed three inches and are one of the few genus well suited for the popular 30ish gallon cube systems. Pair only with appropriate tankmates, as a Wetmorella species which is picked on will lead to its demise.


    Mixing Different Species, of the Same and Different Genus
    Mixing wrasses of different species or genus is generally possible. While there is no exact science to this, there are certainly some guidelines. Please bear in mind, even with these guidelines, results when mixing wrasses will be variable and a conscious aquarist should be mindful of this and keep a close eye on a system with mixed species to observe for any problematic aggression. What's problematic aggression you ask? This should be defined as any chasing which results in attack or nipping, or one wrasse constantly pushing another into hiding. It is entirely normal to see some occasional (brief) chasing and very normal to see some flashing between two wrasses.; the later of which is one of the positive benefits of keeping different species together, as the Fairy and Flasher wrasses are most stunning while performing this act.

    Two exceptions which should be noted first: Various species of wrasses of the genus Pseudocheilinus should not be mixed in the same system, unless it’s several hundred gallons. Also, caution should be expressed when mixing various species within the Macropharyngodon genus. This can usually be done with acceptable results, but sometimes can be problematic. Close observation is required. The bigger your tank, the more likely you’ll be at success here.

    The one rule to never violate is keeping two dominant males of the same species together. This might work for a while, but surely will not end well. Furthermore, unless you are an experienced keeper, I would not advise two males of the same species together. While it is possible to have a dominant and sub-dominant male in the same system, please don’t give it a try unless you know what you’re doing.

    Males of different species can be kept together, within the same genus (there’s a few species/species combination exceptions) or between different genera. The system must be large enough however, say at least 100 gallons or so. Females of any species/genus will almost always mix just fine.

    A pair/trio/etc of one species may also be kept with the same of another species, and often works quite well as the males will be too pre-occupied with the conspecific females to pay attention to much else. However, as I said before, there is no guarantee a female will stay female, and may transition to male for various reasons. Sometimes this now sub-dominant male will “work things out” with the dominant male, other times they will not and you’ll end up one less fish. Again, an observant aquarist is required and one should intervene when necessary.

    When adding new wrasses to a system already containing established wrasses, an acclimation box is a must. Place the new arrivals in the box for 2-3 days before releasing. During this time, observe the interaction between the new arrivals and the established tankmates. If aggressive behavior is witnessed and does not subside, you had best rethink the release of the new additions. You may want to extend the acclimation period (say 4-5 days) and observe if the behavior subsides or changes. Generally, the acclimation box gives everyone enough time to “size each other up”, and much potentially aggression is avoided as the hierarchy becomes established through visual interaction.

    There are a few options for acclimation boxes currently on the market. Elite Aquatics offers two different sizes (I prefer the larger): http://www.elite-aquatics.net/index.php?route=product/category&path=43 Also, the AccliMate by Reef Gently would work for the purpose. While pricer, it does offer additional functionality, and may make an efficient fish trap if you need to remove an established fish later down the road for various reasons: (direct: http://reef-gently.com via Marine Depot: http://www.marinedepot.com/Reef_Gen...Aquariums-Reef_Gently-RG1111-FIMIATTK-vi.html).


    List of Popular Species (by Genus) Available in the USA

    Anampses

    A. caeruleopunctatus “Blue Spotted Tamarin”: Occasionally available & affordable, but does reach quite a large size (16"). Mature adults are very different in appearance from the juvi's sometimes for sale.

    A. chrysocephalus “Red Tail Tamarin” (female) or “Psych-Head Tamarin” (male): Likely the most popular species of this genus, and can fair well if you pick according to the aforementioned guidelines. Females adapt to captivity better than males.

    A. femininus “Blue-Striped Tamarin”: Absolutely stunning, with an equally stunning price tag, when rarely available

    A. lennardi “Lennardi Wrasse” or “Blue and Yellow Wrasse”: Almost as beautiful as the A. femininus, but has a more broken pattern. This is cooler water fish, and will not do well above 76F. At this time, long term success with this fish has been non-existent. May require an even cooler environment.

    A. meleagrides “Yellow-tail Tamarin”: Very similar to the Red-Tail Tamarin, just with a yellow tail. Same comments apply.

    A. neoguinaicus “Black-Backed Tamarin”: Rarely available, as it's a poor intercontinental shipper. But when available, and in good health, can be a great addition.

    A. twistii “Yellow-Breasted Tamarin”: Often available and affordable. One of the smallest Anampses, but can sometimes be a bit more aggressive than most (still rather mild, however).


    Cirrhilabrus

    C. adornatus “Adorned Fairy”: Generally available in the trade, not overly expensive. Is almost always aggressive with other Cirrhilabrus..

    C. aurantidorsalis “Orange-Backed Fairy”: Very saturated colors and not overly expensive. Usually peaceful with other Cirrhilabrus.

    C. balteatus “Gridled Fairy”: Somewhat rare in the trade, moderately priced. Occasionally aggressive with other Cirrhilabrus.

    C. bathiphilus “Hooded Fairy”: Somewhat rare in the trade, expensive but beautiful. Three known regional variants. Can be somewhat aggressive with other Cirrhilabrus once established, but usually not to the point which will prohibit others.

    C. beauperryi “Beau's Fairy”: Somewhat rare in the trade; closely related to C. punctatus. Usually peaceful with other Cirrhilabrus.

    C. condei “Conde’s Fairy”: Often available, inexpensive. Usually aggressive.

    C. cyanopleura “Blue-Sided Fairy”: One of the larger species in the genus (6”). Usually peaceful. There is a great deal of variation within this species depending upon collection region.

    C. earlei “Earl's Fairy”: Rarely available and very expensive. Collection is remote and requires rather deep diving. Usually peaceful with other Cirrhilabrus.

    C. exquisitus “Exquisite Fairy”: Commonly available, not overly expensive. There is color variation amongst the species dependant upon collection region. Be warned, males of this species are known to fade in color if not kept with females. Peaceful.

    C. filamentosus “Whip-Fin Fairy”: Commonly available, inexpensive. One of the more aggressive Cirrhilabrus. Use extreme caution if mixing with other Cirrhilabrus.

    C. flavidorsalis “Yellow-fin Fairy”: One of the smallest of the genus. Often available at an affordable cost. While generally not overly aggressive, they will stand their ground quite well for their size.

    C. joanallenae “Joan's Fairy”: Sometimes available, somewhat affordable. Closely related to rubriventralis and can be differentiated by the pelvic fins being entirely black. Can sometimes be aggressive with other Cirrhilabrus.

    [begin truncation - updated version here: http://www.reef2reef.com/threads/all-about-reef-safe-wrasses-in-aquaria.259894/ ]
     
    Last edited: Nov 23, 2016
    April Hope, Vu Nguyen, SnoQ and 12 others like this.
  2. Click Here!

  3. dpruitt7450

    dpruitt7450 Bubble Tip Anemone

    Joined:
    May 17, 2009
    Messages:
    671
    Location:
    St.Pete FL
  4. starfish2217

    starfish2217 Horrid Stonefish

    Joined:
    Jul 27, 2010
    Messages:
    2,089
    I was totally going to tell you to do a write up about wrasses, I was going to PM you and ask you a few Q's!! thanks !
     
  5. Travis45

    Travis45 Scooter Blennie

    Joined:
    Feb 18, 2009
    Messages:
    1,205
    Wow this a great write up!!! Awesome job Evolved!!!
     
  6. evolved

    evolved Wrasse Freak

    Joined:
    Feb 26, 2010
    Messages:
    4,257
    Location:
    Phoenix, AZ
    Thank you.

    Thanks. Feel free to PM me if you have specific questions.

    I was hoping to have this out sooner, but as you can imagine this took just a few hours. ;)

    Thank you sir.
     
  7. JJL

    JJL Purple Tang

    Joined:
    Jan 5, 2011
    Messages:
    1,818
    Very cool writeup!
    Thanks, evolved!
     
  8. Click Here!

  9. SkyFire

    SkyFire Clown Trigger

    Joined:
    Jan 31, 2010
    Messages:
    2,009
    Location:
    Sacramento CA
    Nice write up thanks.

    This verified that my choices of wrasses to add to my tank were good, giving me much peace of mind.
     
    Last edited: Sep 13, 2011
  10. Atticus818

    Atticus818 Eyelash Blennie

    Joined:
    Oct 19, 2010
    Messages:
    1,281
    Location:
    Southern California
    You finished! Congrats! Great article evolved.
     
  11. ReefBruh

    ReefBruh Giant Squid

    Joined:
    Jul 11, 2010
    Messages:
    4,812
    Location:
    Clearwater, FL
    Excellent article you wrote. Makes everything easy to understand now.
     
  12. M-Ocean Man

    M-Ocean Man Flame Angel

    Joined:
    May 4, 2010
    Messages:
    1,545
    Location:
    Dirty Jerz
    Very helpful - I was not aware that Sixlines (have one) were so aggressive toward other wrasses! I'll be sure not to be looking into any wrasses for my DT soon!