Does either of these First ZOA/SHROOM/RIC setup sound good?

ItemItem NameSourcePriceShipping* Expensive to start but easy to upgrade to SPS Tank20"x15"x5" ACRYLIC ALL IN ONE FRAG TANKebay - Advance Acrylics$125 $29.50 LightCoralife Aqualight Single Linear Strip Compact Fluorescent Fixture 20 inchmarineandreef.com99.95$11.63 Filterwet/dry/fuge included with tankFlowRio 50 Water PumpAmazon Stingrays$11.75 pros: better filtration cons: smaller tank Total$277.83 Cheaper outlook that will still last but hard to change and multiple points of failure Tank30 Gallon CubeGreat Lakes Aquarium$69.95 LightCoralife 24" Lunar AqualightAmazon Stingrays$161.04 FilterMarineland Penguin 150 Power FilterAmazon Stingrays$23.99 FlowAquaclear 20 PowerheadAmazon Stingrays pre-boughtpros: bigger tank, good lighting, no shipping wait cons: filtrationTotal$254.98

 

I think the second one because it is a larger tank giving you more room for error, if it has the ability to use 24" fixtures you will have more lighting options, you choose the filtration.