Am I overdosing elements ?

As I stated before I use RedSea Marine Trace & Calcium + 3 once a week as directed on the bottel today I was board an looked up all the elements on the bottle of marine trace and found there were some that were in both products below are whats in marine trace 2 of which are in the C+3
just want to know what you guys may think

Marine Trace

Iodine - I
Molybdenum - Mo
Zinc - Zn
Vanadium - V
Arsenic - As
Titanium - Ti
Nickel - Ni
Chromium - Cr
Manganese - Mn
Cobalt - Co
Selenium - Se
Tungsten - W
Silver - Ag
Bismuth - Bi
Antimony - Sb
Tin - Sn
Niobium - Nb
Beryllium - Be
Gold - Au
Indium - In
Yttrium - Y

C+3

Calcium - Strrontium - Iodine - Molybdenum both I & MO are in both

 

i don't think you have enough corals to warrant dosing

 

Its mostly for my fish and live rock

 

well i don't think the silver and arsenic are helping the fish lol

do you do water changes?

 

Your fish wont benefit from those elements as much as the corals will. Luna

 

yes but thing is its 2 products so i cant pick and chose elements

read this

RedSeaFish

 

the thing is with dosing if you do build up a high enough concentration of half those chemicals listed it becomes posioness

 

the funny thing is I looked up every element my self they dont tell you that on the bottle but i have benn using this product for years

 

this is all it says

Contains the following elements:
I, Mo, Zn, V, As, Ti, Ni, Cr, Mn, Co, Se, W, Ge, Ag, Bi, Sb, Sn, Nb, Be, Au, In, Y.

 

The only ppl that benefit from that article is RedSea. If you only have fish, regular WC will take care of all that. The only time that you would need that, is when you are over stocked and the WC arent enough or if your not doing WC's. If you do WC's and dose that stuff, your over dosing and throwing away your money everytime you do a WC. Did I make any sense? Luna