My experience with Elegance Coral

Discussion in 'LPS Corals' started by abeliski, Dec 15, 2013.

to remove this notice and enjoy 3reef content with less ads. 3reef membership is free.

  1. abeliski

    abeliski Plankton

    Joined:
    Dec 15, 2013
    Messages:
    4
    I want to share my experience with elegance corals that I've had since August, and my thoughts on acclimating, and how it reacts to supplements such as essential trace elements and calcium supplements and feeding.

    So I've always been fascinated about elegance corals, and I might add that it's because of this particular beautiful corals that kept me going on reef keeping. Since starting my tank with a 29 gallon HQI biocube three years ago I have been persistent in trying to get elegance coral to survive more than two weeks in my tank.

    What I found out that the HQI biocube's lighting is way too intense for elegance. No matter how hard I try to hide elegance under shades and indirect water flow, I never have any success with it. Like many aquarists and enthusiasts documented in numerous forum posts, none have survived past two weeks and at most a month at best before it withered and died.

    I have since upgraded to a 66 gallon red sea max tank and been running it since July 2013. As usual I started with a pretty light bio load, then slowly adding one coral at a time in a two week increment, now to the point that my tank is completely full, with some fish.

    I started with an indo elegance coral in last week of July in the partially shaded area. When it showed signs of "somewhat" happy, I would move it into a fully lighted area. Three weeks later I got an aussie elegance coral, again acclimating it in the same partially shaded area. See attachment 1. The one in the front of the tank is an indo elegance, and the one in the back is an aussie. Appearance wise, there was no difference. Both skeletons were pretty clean, although some aquarists have mentioned that indo elegance coral's skeleton tends to be darker.

    The indo elegance never fully expand to its fullest. As you can see in attachment 1, this was two hours after I introduced the aussie, and it was OK, not completely happy, but nonetheless, somewhat expanded. The same day I offered both of them chopped fresh shrimp, and both readily took food and digested them.

    However, a week later, the indo elegance started to retract and stop taking food altogether. But the aussie elegance have fully expanded in the shaded area and was very happy. Its tentacles were long and flowing. See attachment 2.

    When the indo elegance finally gave out and died, and the aussie elegance had expanded to the point where its flesh was pressing against my tank glass, I moved it into an area where I hope it would grow into. See attachment 3, where the photo was taken right after I moved it into an fully lighted area. The same day I offered it more chopped shrimp and the next day, it expanded even more. See attachment 4.

    Two days later, I left for a 9 day vacation, and something unfortunate happened while I was away. My carpet anemone decided to move into the area where I had placed my aussie elegance coral. When I returned, I found it distraught and had been stung by the potent carpet anemone. It was unhappy, but none the less still readily to take food from me. I decided to move it away from the anemone. And from then on, I prayed that it would continue to survive after it has been stung the crap out of it by the anemone, but it was an up hill battle. Day after day, it started to retract, and began losing its color. See attachment 5.

    Then I was plagued by the red slime cyno bacteria, resorting me to chemically treating my tank and constantly doing water change every 48 hours. And within 8 days, my carpet anemone died. Once my anemone was out of the tank, I moved the coral back to where it was. It was not happy due to the constant change in water change. My guess is each time I changed water, I also removed the beneficial bacteria as well...

    ... continue to next post ...
     

    Attached Files:

  2. Click Here!

  3. abeliski

    abeliski Plankton

    Joined:
    Dec 15, 2013
    Messages:
    4
    My experience with Elegance Coral (continues)

    Once my water parameters were stable again, but saw no improvement in the health of the aussie elegance coral, I decided to try to dose my tank with a drop of Lugol's solution everyday. I saw some improvement, but the results were not consistent.

    Each week after my water change, I only saw a small improvement in its appearance. Feeling helpless, I decided to start dosing my tank with calcium, 5ml each day. I saw improvement right away. So it was happy with additional calcium in the water that I provide, but it was not the same glorious beauty that I saw right before my 9-day vacation.

    Then I began researching all-in-one trace elements supplements: strontium, barium, magnesium, indium, bromium, fluorine, manganese, chromium, copper, nickel, potassium,, zinc, lithium, boron, cobalt, rubidium. That's where I found Korallen-Zucht.de's Meerwasser Komplex Concentrate. This product is expensive, but I decided to give it a shot. I also got from the same manufacturer Pohl's Xtra Special Colour enhancement for hard corals.

    Within two days of using these two products, the elegance coral fully expanded, and its colors were glowing like I had never seen before. However, the Meerwasser Komplex Concentrate does state that do not use this product and ZEOvit system together. I failed to see that. See, ZEOvit Coral vitalizer really brings out the color and expansion in SPS. The first day I use the ZEOvit coral food concentrate, my elegance coral complained to me that it wasn't happy. Its tentacles retracted, and its flesh swelled. Seeing the side effects, I stopped using the ZEOvit coral food concentrate immediately. Within 24 hours, my elegance coral was happy again, fully expanded, it's tentacles swaying in the water like an anemone.

    Around this time, I introduce several more aussie elegance corals and another indo elegance coral. The large neon green aussie on the sand bed, and the other smaller one I glued to the rock, they were happy. See attachment 1.

    But then, strange as it may seem, the large neon green elegance, who was happy for about a month began to bleach. After it bleached to the point where its flesh is now completely transparent, it still alive and its tentacles still long and flowing, readily to take food from me, its color never returned, and I have decided to move it into a more shaded area in hopes it will recover to its former glory. The small neon green, however, continues to do well. So is the indo elegance coral.

    The first aussie elegance I introduced into the tank four months ago continues to grow, now the space it occupies barely has enough room for its flesh when it's fully expanded.

    Why one elegance excels under the same condition where the other bleaches, I have no explanation whatsoever.

    I started dosing Korallen-Zucht.de's LPS Amino Acid concentrate and Sponge power, ZEOfood and ZEObak four days ago, because I have clams and other filter feeders in my tank. The dosing of four additional products have no adverse effects on my elegance coral, rather, the ZEObak clears my water.

    Is aussie elegance corals much superior to their indo elegance cousins? Time will tell. But one thing is for certain, the indo elegance I introduced a week after I introduced the large neon aussie elegance didn't bleach but rather continues to do well in the tank. Its tentacles are not as long and flowing like its aussie's cousin, it didn't wither and shrink and die. At least not yet, so I keep my fingers crossed.

    One thing is for sure, elegance corals like mild water flow. The milder the water flow the longer their tentacles extend. And having stable amount of calcium and essential trace elements make them happy. Feeding is important, too. They like chopped fresh shrimp or scollops. If you get your shrimp and scollops from the grocery store, make sure you soak them for 20 minutes, chopped them, then rinse the chopped meat several more times to remove as much phosphate from the food as possible.

    Attachment 2 was taken last night to show you how big the first aussue elegance coral I introduced into the tank four months ago has grown 3 times larger since then. I have moved it back to its original resting place to give it room to grow. I believe it's a keeper, so are the other numerous smaller ones. ;)
     

    Attached Files:

    1 person likes this.
  4. Corailline

    Corailline Super Moderator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Sep 8, 2010
    Messages:
    19,652
    Location:
    It is a dry heat, yeah right !
    Welcome to 3reef abeliski.

    Great personal observations and write up. You have a beautiful coral there. I found the information regarding feedings and supplement information interesting. In my opinion you're spot on about the HQI being too intense for the coral.
    It's been my experience that this coral does better in tanks with more nutrients and lower flow, basically not the same ideal environment for the pristine reef tanks most hobbyist strive for.
     
  5. abeliski

    abeliski Plankton

    Joined:
    Dec 15, 2013
    Messages:
    4
    My tank at glance

    Yes I agreed. The Red Sea Max light is intense but I think it's just right for all kinds of corals to thrive.

    ;D
     

    Attached Files:

  6. Corailline

    Corailline Super Moderator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Sep 8, 2010
    Messages:
    19,652
    Location:
    It is a dry heat, yeah right !
    Why you show off you.;)Stunning tank, thank you for sharing. :)
     
  7. Marshall O

    Marshall O Giant Squid

    Joined:
    Jun 19, 2012
    Messages:
    3,517
    Location:
    Central MA
    Wow, how long have you had that many clowns together? Beautiful tank though!!
     
  8. Click Here!

  9. abeliski

    abeliski Plankton

    Joined:
    Dec 15, 2013
    Messages:
    4
    I started my tank in July, cycled it for two weeks and was good to go. Right away I introduced all my clowns together: 1 pair of percula, 1 pair of maldives, 1 pair of pink, 1 pair of fire clown, 1 pair of maroon, and 1 pair of clarkii.

    One of the fire clowns didn't make to the second day due to shipping stress, they're allegedly very delicate clown originated around the sea in Taiwan. one of the maldives died two months later, and a tiny maroon got eaten by my carpet (anemone now gone). I never did reintroduce another maldives clown, but decided to reintroduce another maroon and fire clown, and another pair of picasso and orange skunk. It took the maroon about 1 week to pair up. I like to push boundaries. And none of them clowns came as a pair when I bought them. No one got hurt or anything. So it's all very possible to have different clowns in the same tank. They chased one another for about 4 hours the first day and that was it. There were so many of them and they didn't know who to get aggressive with and just gave up. Now they're like one big happy family. The Maroon is not the most aggressive, but rather the Maldives. Occasionally she would chase the other off the riterri but does allow the the pink skunk pair to share her anemone since day one.

    The fiji leather on the lower left side of the tank is a frag I cut from my 29-gal bio cube before my 9 day vacation in september, and is now growing my weeds. Sadly the mother died in my bio cube, so I'm waiting for the frag to get quite a bit bigger before I frag one of the stems and seed it back in my bio cube. I added the pulsating xenia in early August that came in a piece of rock that I stuck in the middle of the tank, and xenia polyps were a size of two quarters and now spreading in all four directions. Below the red brain coral in the upper middle of tank is the elongated xenia a friend of mine grew tired of, and it was the size of my fist when given to me but now is almost a foot across.

    The meat coral between the fungia and brain on the sand bed were damaged during my 9-day vacation, too, when my frogspawn (upper left hand corner) got knocked off by my emerald crab and fell on it and stung the crap out of it. one quarter of its tissues got damaged and recessed. Took me a month to slowly nursed it back to life by feeding it chopped shrimp, now fully recovered and tissues regenerated; also glued my frogspawn shut to my live rock to prevent any future catastrophe.

    Any uneaten chopped shrimp my emerald crabs, peppermint shrimps and fire shrimp devour them. I have several emerald crabs that were the size of a nickle now almost three inches across. Too bad they're so damn hard to catch otherwise I would re-home some of them to my bio cube instead of having to buy more.

    I do get some green algae built up each day on the sand bed where water flow don't get to but the cucumbers (two of them) take care of them each night so each day the tank start fresh with a clean sand bed. I do have to clean my glass once a day. That's just routine so no complaint here.

    All and all, bacteria are abundant and I can see them on my tank glass, which make my yellow wrasse and mandarin goby happy and fed. I do try to change water every week but all depending on what I see. If water appears clear and no film on the surface I go two weeks before a 5 gal water change (10%).

    Now I want to train my dendro and orange sun and black sun to come out during the day. It's no fun when they only show themselves while I'm at sleep.
     
    Last edited: Dec 16, 2013
  10. Swisswiss

    Swisswiss Caribbean Reef Squid

    Joined:
    Jul 25, 2011
    Messages:
    2,879
    Location:
    Geneva Switzerland
    interesting read, thx for sharing your experiences