Tank of X Gallons [If you have a problem to where a fish is listed]

This is the debate only thread. Please keep debate to an ABSOLUTE minimum. If you feel that a certain listing of a fish is VERY WRONG please make note of it here. That does not mean you think the listing is 10 gallons off.
If you do not know what this is: http://www.3reef.com/forums/tropical-fish/fish-ideas-tank-x-gallons-110656.html
Official Thread:http://www.3reef.com/forums/tropical-fish/fish-ideas-tank-x-gallons-official-thread-110722.html

Thanks
JJL

 

Im not sure I understand this thread or the question you are asking....Maybe im missing something.

 

I think what you are trying to say is....If say liveaquaria has a fish that says 20-55 gallons min but really the fish should be kept in 125+ gallons, is that what you mean?

 

I am not asking a question...LOL
When this list is complete it will be for begginers in the hobby
It could possibly be made into a sticky (If it is good enough)
JJL

 

He started a thread for giving min tank sizes, but if you disagree by more than 10-15 gallons in tank size, post here.

 

Thanks for clearing that up, thepanfish
JJL

 

Thank you, I must have missed the first thread, if you can throw a link to that thread in the intro to this thread. That way we can click over to it. Just a suggestion so people like me may not be confused. Thank you for clearing it up, I hope I can contribute!

 

I put a link into the official thread. I will put one here too
JJL

 

Oh, (slaps head) almost forgot Royal Grammas! You are welcome JJL, I hope this thread will get off the ground and not turn into a massive argument here. This is a good idea, and I think excluding fish like tangs and mandarins, this will keep from arguments.

 

i hope this thread turns out good haha